Milking the banks for miles
First time here? Check out the site's "greatest hits" or read a random post from the archives. Feel free to ask a question, and consider subscribing to the latest posts via RSS or e-mail. Thanks for visiting!
Keith Alexander offers this fantastic example of the potential frequent flyer mileage you can earn with a credit card:
Ann Scharpf of Huntingtown, Md., scouted around for about 40 friends, neighbors and co-workers who were willing to help her pump her American Airlines Citibank card. She would use her card to cover their groceries and other necessities if they would reimburse her.
Within two months, Scharpf was paying co-workers’ car insurance. And on Saturday mornings, she would buy grocery-store gift cards on her credit card totaling $100 to $800, then hand them over and collect the money from her friends and co-workers. Next, she would deposit the cash and pay off the balance on her card. Once, a Citibank representative called her to inquire why in one day she had bought $1,500 at a Food Lion and then $3,500 at the Giant Food across the street.
Ann Scharpf, I salute you! You just entered the frequent flyer hall of fame in my book. Paying co-workers’ car insurance?!? Hard-freakin’-core. And I thought I was doing well by charging all of my OWN expenses to the card…
At the same time, Alexander cites oft-heard complaints that finding awards you want is hard, and that the “annual credit card fees of $60 to $85, depending on the airline and the credit card, also make the cards less attractive.”
I agree that, if you pay an annual fee for a credit card, you’d better be getting your money’s worth. And you’d better not carry a balance, because the airline-linked cards carry high rates.
Let’s assign an overly conservative value of 1 cent per mile to the miles you earn. If you’re paying a $50 annual fee for your credit card, you’re not breaking even until you’ve earned 5000 miles with your card. If you’re paying $85, the break-even threshold is 8500 miles, etc.
But AFTER you cross that point, I contend the cards are still worth it. (And my 1 cent/mile standard is too tough.) True, hoarding miles is stupid, since miles don’t earn interest and are a devaluing currency, but their value isn’t fixed, either: You can get 1 cent per mile if you cash in your points for a ticket you could buy with cash during a fare sale, or you could get 8 or even 10 cents per mile when you redeem an international premium-class award. (Unsure if it’s better to spend money or miles? Run through the Miles or Buy tutorial.)
Plus, the bonuses you can earn with mileage credit cards are sometimes nutty, and annual-fee waiver offers come around, too. At the low end of bonuses, there’s the Northwest WorldPerks Visa Signature: One current offer gives you 7500 bonus miles with a $90 annual fee, or 5000 bonus miles with a $55 fee, which frankly isn’t great. At the upper end, there’s a United Mileage Plus Visa Signature with the first year’s fee waived and 20,000 bonus miles. And that’s before you spend anything on the card! Even the low-bonus card might be worth it if it earns you sufficient miles through your usage.
Plus, cards are constantly offering bonuses, such as “spend $300 on groceries this month and get double miles,” bonus miles for buying from specific merchants, or annual “anniversary” bonuses. If you tally it up at the end of the year, and you’re not earning more than 1 mile per dollar charged to the card, it may be time for a new card.
Also, some airlines and banks have agreements to offer annual fee rebates to top tier elites. Even better!
Ditch my mileage card? No way. Now if only I could find some trustworthy suckers who will let me charge their car insurance and reimburse me…
(image)
tags: travel | frequent flyer miles | credit cards





Subscribe to Posts by Email