Every so often, a rant about travel comes across so wrong-headed that it deserves to be held under the microscope for scrutiny. Charles DeLaFuente, one of the New York Times’ in-house stable of journalist-bloggers, wins that honor thanks to a recent post. It’s notable for its misguided attempt to assign blame for a travel mishap to all parties other than himself. But nonetheless, travelers, airports, and airlines can all learn from his account, both before and after his flight.

DeLaFuente and his family missed a JetBlue flight at Newark Airport. He blamed the airport’s (and airline’s) lack of sufficient signage to help him find his gate:

Jet Blue has two gates in a concourse also used by Continental, but only Continental has signs at the security area that leads to its seven gates in Terminal A, along with monitors showing the departures from them. Jet Blue has nothing there to alert passengers that its gates lie in that concourse, too.

Granted, I would have seen the Jet Blue counter and the monitors showing gates 21 and 22 if I had entered the terminal on the upper level, where anyone dropped off by private car or taxi, or with bags to check, would normally arrive.

But many passengers enter at the terminal’s ground level, where shuttle buses stop. And if, like me, they have no bags to check, they go up the escalators and emerge at the security checkpoint without ever passing the Jet Blue check-in counter. That’s where it can get confusing. There are three concourses in the terminal. Behind which one do the Jet Blue gates lie?

When I read this, I thought, “You have to be kidding me.” Newark’s terminal A is divided like a split level house. The upper level is a short, half-level escalator ride from the level where you enter security. If there were no flight monitors immediately visible (…aren’t they also at security?), then a few steps up the escalator, and voila.

This photo appears to be from the C-terminal, if I’m not mistaken, but the basic architecture is the same, and should gives you a sense of the distance involved between the top (check-in) and middle (security/gates) levels at Newark:

newark airport escalator Taking some responsibility for a missed flight: A bad example from the NYT

And when you reach the top of the escalator on the check-in level, there are monitors listing the flights (this image is from Terminal A):

newark terminal a Taking some responsibility for a missed flight: A bad example from the NYT

So, I’m sorry, it’s really not that hard to find your flight’s gate at Newark.

But DeLaFuente’s rant gets worse:

I arrived at the terminal with my teenage son and daughter about 30 minutes before flight time, then spent about 10 minutes searching for the right concourse and maybe 10 minutes waiting in the security line.

Hold on: DeLaFuente left himself only 30 minutes from the moment of arrival to the moment of departure? At Newark? When he didn’t know where he was going?

Sure, the airlines will tell you to arrive early and to leave abundant time for your flight. And there are plenty of us who leave less time than the recommended 1 hour+ cushion, especially if we know the airport well. (The TSA’s security line wait time estimator is unfortunately down for the time being, though when it’s up, it can be of help in planning things, too.) But 30 minutes at Newark, one of America’s busiest airports, is begging for trouble. I’ve spent nearly that long in security lines there.

To his credit, DeLaFuente raises a few valid points. Jetblue could have been nice and let him standby for the next flight without charging him extra, instead of upcharging him. Their customer relations staff should have written back to him when he sent a certified letter of complaint to their CEO (which was the wrong way to escalate a complaint, but that’s another issue…). And Newark Airport and Jetblue should, yes, consider placing monitors differently, or in more places.

But I find it nearly impossible to show sympathy for someone who arrives 30 minutes before departure from Newark, isn’t capable of taking an escalator up a half flight of stairs, and won’t take any responsibility for his actions.

Categorized in: airports, travel
6 Comments

6 Responses to “Taking some responsibility for a missed flight: A bad example from the NYT”

  1. Peter Says:

    If this guy by-passed the checkin counter then he would have had his boarding ticket pre-printed in order to go directly to security, right? That boarding ticket would have had the terminal/gate on it, right? Admittedly, I don’t fly JB that often, so I can’t recall exactly what their boarding ticket looks like, but I’m with you — if I don’t know exactly where I am going, I’m going to get there way, way, way before 30 minutes!

  2. Mark Ashley Says:

    Peter,

    Yes, indeed, he had a boarding pass, printed at home. I’ll paste the snippet from his post below where he admits this, and admits the boarding pass included a gate number on it, too.

    Now, granted, gates are subject to change, but for an airline like JetBlue, which has a small presence at Newark, it’s a limited number of possibilities. And would it kill him to try the gate that’s printed on the pass first?

    The promised snippet:

    Still simmering, I sued in small-claims court. The day before the trial, a Jet Blue paralegal called to ask what my suit was all about. She did not have my letter, so I told her my story.

    I suppose such employees guard their company’s treasuries, not their reputations, so the conversation, while civil, wasn’t exactly warm. The paralegal’s position, repeated again and again, was that my boarding pass had the gate number printed on it. I had printed the boarding passes at home, and each computer and printer configures online documents differently, so who knows.

    (emphasis added)

    “So who knows.” Wow. Now it’s the printer’s fault.

  3. Oliver Says:

    Right. It’s really strange. My printer for whatever bizarre reason prints the boarding pass in ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs. I always get a hard time at the TSA checkpoints with it, too.

    What a bozo! And seriously, the NY Times pays this guy? If he’s that stupid, they just lost a whole lot of respect for the quality of their writers.

  4. Tino Says:

    Indeed, it’s awful. Pathetic. Embarrassing. And I’m referring to the editors who allowed this kind of garbage to stand under the New York Times masthead.

    Since when is it okay to include “so who knows” as an explanation for anything in this nation’s paper of record? Neither the writer nor the editor has an excuse for letting that slide.

    It was even in the Sunday paper, and not “just” online.

    The next time Bill Keller bashes blogs and the pain they’re causing his business model, you, Mark, should send him this post and remind him of the way the NYT is slashing its own credibility and killing itself slowly.

  5. Mike Maddaloni - @thehotiron Says:

    For me, there is no such thing as getting to an airport too early. Pack a book and a few dollars to have a drink if you have to wait!

    mp/m

Leave a Reply