14
Mar
2006
Posted by: Mark Ashley

The Wall Street Journal (subscription required) rehashes the recent report that cellphones cause interference to aircraft navigation instruments. (previously discussed here and here)

The real nugget in the article, though, is this:

Do travelers really want to gab inflight? Of 8,000 comments to the FCC when it proposed dropping its ban, only two or three were in favor. The rest, except for the 50 or so technical reports, were from travelers vociferously opposed, arguing that airplanes should be a refuge from calls and emails. Flight attendant unions are also opposed, fearing obnoxious phone habits could lead to air-rage incidents.

That’s quite a supermajority opposed to cellphones inflight. Count me in, unless the loud talkers are relegated to a private area in the back of the plane.

The opposition to e-mail doesn’t make as much sense to me — if planes are equipped with internet access, passengers will have the choice to read/write e-mail, or not. It’s not really any different than typing a manuscript on your laptop, and is hardly intrusive on your neighbors. Phone conversations are a different matter entirely.

4 Comments

4 Responses to “7947 travelers can’t be wrong”

  1. Fly Girl Says:

    Maybe we’ll see a non-cell phone portion of the cabin. Sort of like the old days of smoking or non-smoking.

    Both seem to keep the individual happy while annoying the hell out of those around them.

  2. Upgrade: Travel Better » Blog Archive » Individual airlines start to clarify cellphone use policies Says:

    [...] latest posts via RSS or e-mail. Thanks for visiting!USA Today’s Ben Mutzabaugh follows up the recent fracas over possible cellphone use in flight by contacting individual airlines and asking them what their [...]

  3. Air France to allow cellphones in flight » Upgrade: Travel Better Says:

    [...] the U.S., public opposition to cellphones in flight is fairly strong, but Europe looks like it may go the other [...]

  4. Emirates promises (or threatens inflight cellphones on longhaul flights » Upgrade: Travel Better) Says:

    [...] – “No Cellphones” light to be added to aircraft interiors – 7947 travelers can’t be wrong – Air France to allow cellphones in [...]

Leave a Reply